Yes, it was! And I am happy to have good debates. I always try to approach things this way, and not as mean-spirited arguments. There just isn't time in life to have super-angry flame wars on message boards, but a good debate/discussion is always OK.
Let me frame this another way (at the admitted risk of starting an analogy arms race, which is really not my intention): You like the Friday the 13th movies, right? I know I do. But I hate Jason Goes to Hell. I mean, that movie is please-give-me-that-90-minutes-of-my-life-back bad. It's unbearable. I don't like that it exists, because it suggests things about Jason that don't and will never make sense to me, within the context of what else Friday the 13th has shown me. But just because I can't stand that movie, doesn't mean I'm going to ignore or disregard the other good and fun things that this series has given me. Just because this one specific thing irks me, it absolutely does not invalidate the rest of the value that the series has provided.
(I know I'm stretching here, because the quality of those movies is a bit questionable here and there. But you get my point, I hope.)
(P.S. Don't even get me started on how I would apply this analogy to some of the later Halloween movies...)